A Youtube video attempts to prooftext God’s immutability:
Psa 33:11 The counsel of the LORD stands forever, the plans of his heart to all generations.
Does this mean God is immutable? How does someone read this and then come to the conclusion: “this means that God can not change in any respect, ever.”
1. It is about God’s counsel (God’s plans). In the previous verse the text contrasts God’s counsel with the counsel of nations. God is said to overthrow the nation’s counsel. That, in itself, is a change.
2. The contrast is about plans that can be thwarted and plans that cannot be thwarted. How does this imply immutability?
3. Does the text imply that man’s changeablness is what undid their plans? That seems like an absurd reading.
Psalms 33:11 cannot be reasonably claimed as a prooftext for immutability. For people to use it as a prooftext shows that the evidence for immutability is slim.
Well put! (Chris Fisher?)